Manuscript Peer Review Assessment Template

Manuscript Information

Title Authors Journal Manuscript ID

---

Summary

Brief Summary of the Manuscript

Major Comments

Main Concerns/Improvements Required

Minor Comments

Minor Suggestions or Corrections

Originality

Novelty and Significance

Methods & Analysis

Appropriateness and Description of Methods

Results & Interpretation

Quality and Interpretation of Results

Clarity & Structure

Organization, Language, and Presentation

Ethical Considerations

Compliance with Ethical Standards

Recommendation

Overall Recommendation Additional Remarks