Medical Imaging Article Peer Review Checklist

Article Title:
Manuscript ID:
Reviewer Name:

Checklist

Item Yes No N/A Comments
Is the topic relevant to medical imaging?
Is the abstract concise and informative?
Are objectives clearly stated?
Is the methodology described appropriately?
Are results clearly presented and supported by data?
Are images/tables/figures of high quality and relevant?
Is the discussion comprehensive and critical?
Are conclusions justified by the data presented?
Is proper ethical approval/consent addressed?
Are references current and relevant?
Strengths:
Weaknesses / Suggestions for Improvement:
Confidential Comments to the Editor: