Scientific Manuscript Review Checklist

General

• Is the structure and organization of the manuscript clear?
• Is the language, grammar, and style appropriate and easy to follow?

Abstract

• Does the abstract summarize the key points of the manuscript?
• Is the abstract accurate and concise?

Introduction

• Does the introduction provide adequate background and rationale for the study?
• Are the research questions/hypotheses clearly stated?

Methods

• Are the methods described in sufficient detail to allow replication?
• Are ethical considerations addressed where appropriate?

Results

• Are results presented clearly and logically?
• Are data sufficient to support the conclusions?

Discussion & Conclusion

• Are the results interpreted appropriately and discussed in context?
• Are limitations and implications acknowledged?
• Is the conclusion supported by the data?

References

• Are references accurate and relevant?
• Are references formatted consistently?

Additional Comments