Peer Review Form
Manuscript Submissions (Humanities)

Manuscript Title Author(s) Reviewer Name Reviewer Email Date

---

1. Originality and Significance

Comments

2. Clarity and Organization

Comments

3. Quality of Arguments and Evidence

Comments

4. Engagement with Scholarship

Comments

5. Writing, Style & Presentation

Comments

---

6. Recommendations

Overall Recommendation Accept as is Accept with minor revisions Accept with major revisions Reject Summary & Confidential Comments to Editors Feedback for the Author(s)