Medical Journal Editorial Revision Form
Manuscript Title
Author(s) Name(s)
Manuscript ID
Editorial Decision
Decision
Accept
Minor Revision
Major Revision
Reject
Comments to Author
Comments to Editorial Board (Not sent to author)
Revision Checklist
Have all reviewer comments been addressed?
Yes
No
Partially
Are the methods adequately described?
Yes
No
Are the statistics appropriate and correct?
Yes
No
Is the language and grammar acceptable?
Yes
No
Additional Comments