| Criterion | Excellent | Good | Fair | Poor |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Significance/Purpose | ||||
| Literature Review | ||||
| Research Design/Methods | ||||
| Results/Findings | ||||
| Discussion/Interpretation | ||||
| Conclusions/Implications | ||||
| Organization & Structure | ||||
| Clarity & Style | ||||
| References |
| Accept | |
| Accept with Minor Revision | |
| Major Revision Required | |
| Reject |