Economics Manuscript Reviewer Feedback Checklist

Manuscript Title

Reviewer Name

General Assessment

• Originality/Novelty
• Relevance to Journal Scope
• Contribution to Literature
• Methodological Rigor
• Clarity and Organization
• Quality of References
• Compliance with Ethical Standards

Detailed Comments

Strengths Weaknesses Suggestions for Improvement Other Comments

Recommendation

• Accept
• Minor Revision
• Major Revision
• Reject