Social Sciences Manuscript Critique Form
Manuscript Title
Author(s)
Reviewer Name
Reviewer Email
General Assessment
Summary of the Manuscript
Significance and Originality
Adequacy of Literature Review
Methodology
Appropriateness of Methodology
Clarity of Data Analysis
Results & Discussion
Presentation of Results
Soundness of Interpretation/Discussion
Organization and Style
Clarity and Structure of Writing
Use of Figures, Tables, and References
Ethical Considerations
Ethical Standards Observed
Recommendation
Please select one:
Accept
Minor Revisions
Major Revisions
Reject
Comments to the Author(s)
Confidential Comments to the Editor