Synthetic Chemistry Methods Peer Review Evaluation Form

Manuscript Information

Manuscript Title Authors Manuscript ID

Reviewer Information

Name Email Affiliation

Evaluation Criteria

Originality / Novelty Excellent Good Average Poor Experimental Design and Methodology Excellent Good Average Poor Data Analysis and Interpretation Excellent Good Average Poor Reproducibility and Detail Excellent Good Average Poor Clarity of Presentation Excellent Good Average Poor Significance to the Field Excellent Good Average Poor

Comments

Comments to Authors Comments to Editor

Recommendation

Accept Minor Revision Major Revision Reject