Psychology Meta-Analysis Peer Review Evaluation Form

Manuscript Title

Reviewer Name

Date

1. Clarity and Rationale of Research Question(s)

Comments

2. Inclusion/Exclusion Criteria

Comments

3. Literature Search Strategy

Comments

4. Data Extraction and Coding Procedures

Comments

5. Statistical Analysis and Reporting

Comments

6. Interpretation of Results

Comments

7. Discussion of Limitations and Implications

Comments

8. Overall Quality and Contribution to the Field

Comments

9. Recommendation

Select one

10. Additional Comments to Editors (confidential)

Comments