Clinical Trial Manuscript Peer Review Evaluation Form

Manuscript Information

Manuscript Title Manuscript ID Reviewer Name Date

General Assessment

Summary of Manuscript Overall Impression Excellent Good Fair Poor

Section Evaluation

Section	Evaluation
Title & Abstract	Excellent Good Fair Poor
Introduction/Background	Excellent Good Fair Poor
Methods	Excellent Good Fair Poor
Results	Excellent Good Fair Poor
Discussion/Conclusions	Excellent Good Fair Poor
References	Excellent Good Fair Poor

Critical Appraisal

Ethical Considerations Methodological Strengths & Weaknesses Statistical Analysis Clarity and Presentation

Recommendations

Decision Accept Minor Revision Major Revision Reject Comments to Authors Comments to Editor (confidential)