Food Science Research Manuscript Review Template

Manuscript Title
Manuscript ID

1. Summary of the Manuscript

2. Major Comments

3. Minor Comments

4. Novelty and Significance

Is the research original and significant?

5. Scientific Soundness

Comment on the methodology and the validity of the results.

6. Clarity and Presentation

Is the manuscript clear and well structured?

7. References and Literature

Are references adequate and up-to-date?

8. Recommendation

9. Confidential Comments to Editor