Systematic Literature Review Evaluation Form
1. General Information
Title of Review
Author(s)
Date
Reviewer
2. Review Scope
Research Question(s)
Inclusion Criteria
Exclusion Criteria
3. Search Strategy
Databases Searched
Search Terms/Keywords
Date Range
Other Sources
4. Study Selection
Number of Records Identified
Number of Studies Included
Selection Process Summary
5. Data Extraction
Data Extraction Method
Data Extracted
6. Quality Assessment
Criteria
Assessment
Comments
Clarity of Research Question
Yes
No
Partial
Appropriate Search Strategy
Yes
No
Partial
Transparent Selection Process
Yes
No
Partial
Robust Data Extraction
Yes
No
Partial
Assessment of Bias
Yes
No
Partial
7. Results & Synthesis
Summary of Main Findings
Synthesis Method
Limitations
8. Overall Appraisal
Strengths
Weaknesses
Overall Quality
High
Moderate
Low
9. Additional Comments