Medical Research Peer Review Evaluation Form

Manuscript Information

Title: Authors: Manuscript ID: Reviewer Name: Date:

Evaluation Criteria

1. Originality and Novelty:

Excellent Good Fair Poor

2. Significance of Findings:

Excellent Good Fair Poor

3. Methodology and Design:

Excellent Good Fair Poor

4. Quality of Data and Analysis:

Excellent Good Fair Poor

5. Clarity of Presentation:

Excellent Good Fair Poor

6. Literature Review/References:

Excellent Good Fair Poor

7. Ethical Considerations:

Yes No Not Applicable

Summary Comments

Major Strengths: Major Weaknesses: Specific Comments/Suggestions:

Recommendation