Replication Study Review
1. Study Information
Original Study Title
Authors
Replication Study Title
Reviewer Name
Date
2. Clarity of Replication Goals
Are the goals of the replication clearly described?
3. Methods Appropriateness
Are the methods appropriate and sufficiently similar to the original study?
4. Data and Materials
Are the data and materials used in the replication accessible and appropriate?
5. Results Analysis
Is the analysis of the replicated results clear and justified?
6. Comparison with Original Study
Is the comparison between original and replication results thorough and fair?
7. Transparency and Reporting
Is the study transparently reported and reproducible?
8. Overall Assessment
Summary of strengths and weaknesses
Additional Comments