Academic Research Paper Peer Review Feedback Form

Paper Information

Paper Title Author(s) Reviewer Name Reviewer Email

1. Originality

Is the work original and does it add new knowledge?

Excellent Good Fair Poor

Comments

2. Significance

Significance of the research question, problem or hypothesis

Excellent Good Fair Poor

Comments

3. Methodology

Appropriateness and rigor of methods

Excellent Good Fair Poor

Comments

4. Clarity and Organization

Is the paper clearly written and well organized?

Excellent Good Fair Poor

Comments

5. Interpretation and Analysis

Are the results interpreted appropriately?

Excellent Good Fair Poor

Comments

6. References and Citations

Quality and adequacy of references

Excellent Good Fair Poor

Comments

7. Overall Recommendation

Recommendation Summary of Review